Fast & Discreet Shipping on all Orders
(855) LOV-IFY1 / (855) 568-4391
DropDeals
Track Order
Search
You are only $49.00 away from FREE Standard Shipping
Payments we accept:
Free Shipping on Orders over $59
Menu
Save 30-50% Sex Toy Favorites Free Shipping + Free 60 Day Returns - Join Now
Account

Anal Sex Toys - Most Affordable and High-Quality Butt Plugs. | Fast Checkout with Amazon Pay & Apple Pay | Lovify (37)

37 Items

Set Descending Direction
Filter
View as
  1. B Yours Basic Anal Plug Pink 4.25" B Yours Basic Anal Plug Pink 4.25"

    B Yours Basic Anal Plug Pink 4.25"

    Rating:
    89%
    9  Reviews
    $16.09
    In stock
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  2. Firefly Ace Ii Silicone Glow In The Dark Butt Plug Medium Blue Firefly Ace Ii Silicone Glow In The Dark Butt Plug Medium Blue -37%
    Sold Out

    Firefly Ace Ii Silicone Glow In The Dark Butt Plug Medium Blue

    Special Price $18.99 $29.99
    More on the way!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  3. B Yours Basic Anal Plug 4.25"

    B Yours Basic Anal Plug 4.25"

    $16.09
    In stock
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  4. Firefly Ace II Silicone Glow In The Dark Butt Plug Medium Firefly Ace II Silicone Glow In The Dark Butt Plug Medium -37%

    Firefly Ace II Silicone Glow In The Dark Butt Plug Medium

    $18.99
    In stock
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  5. Booty Bling Large Purple Booty Bling Large Purple

    Booty Bling Large Purple

    $38.49
    In stock
    Only 14 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  6. B Yours Basic Anal Plug Blue 4.25" B Yours Basic Anal Plug Blue 4.25"

    B Yours Basic Anal Plug Blue 4.25"

    Rating:
    68%
    5  Reviews
    $16.09
    In stock
    Only 16 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  7. Booty Bling small Purple Booty Bling small Purple

    Booty Bling small Purple

    $26.68
    In stock
    Only 12 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  8. Booty Bling Small Silver Booty Bling Small Silver

    Booty Bling Small Silver

    $26.68
    In stock
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  9. Booty Bling Large Pink Booty Bling Large Pink

    Booty Bling Large Pink

    $39.99
    In stock
    Only 6 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  10. Colt W/p Power - Anal-t Colt W/p Power - Anal-t -26%

    Colt W/p Power - Anal-t

    Special Price $31.99 $43.49
    In stock
    Only 19 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  11. Interactive Trio Triple Bullets With Dual Controls Soft Rubber Cote 2.2" Blue Interactive Trio Triple Bullets With Dual Controls Soft Rubber Cote 2.2" Blue -30%

    Interactive Trio Triple Bullets With Dual Controls Soft Rubber Cote 2.2" Blue

    Special Price $22.99 $32.99
    In stock
    Only 2 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  12. Mood Naughty Silicone Anal Plug Large Pink Mood Naughty Silicone Anal Plug Large Pink -21%

    Mood Naughty Silicone Anal Plug Large Pink

    Special Price $27.75 $34.99
    In stock
    Only 6 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  13. Mood Naughty Silicone Anal Plug Large Black Mood Naughty Silicone Anal Plug Large Black -21%

    Mood Naughty Silicone Anal Plug Large Black

    Special Price $27.75 $34.99
    In stock
    Only 7 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  14. Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Medium Black Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Medium Black -23%

    Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Medium Black

    Special Price $25.50 $32.99
    In stock
    Only 11 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  15. Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Medium Blue Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Medium Blue -23%
    Sold Out

    Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Medium Blue

    Special Price $25.50 $32.99
    More on the way!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  16. Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Large Black Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Large Black -21%

    Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Large Black

    Special Price $27.75 $34.99
    In stock
    Only 10 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  17. Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Large Blue Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Large Blue -21%
    Sold Out

    Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Large Blue

    Special Price $27.75 $34.99
    More on the way!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  18. Mood Naughty 3 Anal Plug Silicone Black 4.5" Mood Naughty 3 Anal Plug Silicone Black 4.5" -21%

    Mood Naughty 3 Anal Plug Silicone Black 4.5"

    Special Price $27.75 $34.99
    In stock
    Only 4 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  19. Fetish Fantasy Gold Mini Luv Plug Gold 2.4" Fetish Fantasy Gold Mini Luv Plug Gold 2.4" -12%

    Fetish Fantasy Gold Mini Luv Plug Gold 2.4"

    Special Price $39.99 $45.49
    In stock
    Only 15 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  20. Best Seller
    Fetish Fantasy Gold Luv Plug Gold 3.25" Fetish Fantasy Gold Luv Plug Gold 3.25" -16%

    Fetish Fantasy Gold Luv Plug Gold 3.25"

    Special Price $44.99 $53.49
    In stock
    Only 6 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  21. Booty Bling small Pink Booty Bling small Pink

    Booty Bling small Pink

    $26.68
    In stock
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  22. Booty Bling Large Silver Booty Bling Large Silver

    Booty Bling Large Silver

    $39.00
    In stock
    Only 13 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  23. Luxe Candy Rimmer Silicone Anal Plug Large Fuchsia Luxe Candy Rimmer Silicone Anal Plug Large Fuchsia -23%
    Sold Out

    Luxe Candy Rimmer Silicone Anal Plug Large Fuchsia

    Rating:
    100%
    5  Reviews
    Special Price $19.99 $25.99
    More on the way!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  24. Luxe Candy Rimmer Silicone Anal Plug Large Indigo Luxe Candy Rimmer Silicone Anal Plug Large Indigo -23%
    Sold Out

    Luxe Candy Rimmer Silicone Anal Plug Large Indigo

    Special Price $19.99 $25.99
    More on the way!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  25. Calexotics Booty Call Silicone Anal Plug Black Calexotics Booty Call Silicone Anal Plug Black -37%

    Calexotics Booty Call Silicone Anal Plug Black

    Special Price $10.99 $17.49
    In stock
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  26. Firefly Ace Ii Silicone Glow In The Dark Butt Plug Medium Purple Firefly Ace Ii Silicone Glow In The Dark Butt Plug Medium Purple -37%

    Firefly Ace Ii Silicone Glow In The Dark Butt Plug Medium Purple

    Special Price $18.99 $29.99
    In stock
    Only 14 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  27. Best Seller
    Blush Avant Pride P4 Silicone Plug Waterproof Power Play 4.8" Blush Avant Pride P4 Silicone Plug Waterproof Power Play 4.8" -39%
    Sold Out

    Blush Avant Pride P4 Silicone Plug Waterproof Power Play 4.8"

    Rating:
    97%
    12  Reviews
    Special Price $32.99 $53.97
    More on the way!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  28. Blush Avant Pride P5 Silicone Plug Waterproof Fluid 4.8" Blush Avant Pride P5 Silicone Plug Waterproof Fluid 4.8" -19%
    Sold Out

    Blush Avant Pride P5 Silicone Plug Waterproof Fluid 4.8"

    Rating:
    100%
    5  Reviews
    Special Price $34.99 $42.99
    More on the way!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  29. Blush Avant Pride P6 Silicone Plug Waterproof Beyond 4" Blush Avant Pride P6 Silicone Plug Waterproof Beyond 4" -34%

    Blush Avant Pride P6 Silicone Plug Waterproof Beyond 4"

    Rating:
    100%
    5  Reviews
    Special Price $28.99 $44.23
    In stock
    Only 5 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  30. Thump It Rippled Anal Plug Thump It Rippled Anal Plug

    Thump It Rippled Anal Plug

    $126.00
    In stock
    Only 3 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  31. Thump It Swirled Anal Plug Thump It Swirled Anal Plug -13%

    Thump It Swirled Anal Plug

    Special Price $109.99 $126.00
    In stock
    Only 4 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  32. Thump It Missile Anal Plug Thump It Missile Anal Plug -13%

    Thump It Missile Anal Plug

    Special Price $109.99 $126.00
    In stock
    Only 2 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  33. Fantasy for Her Little Gem Large Plug Fantasy for Her Little Gem Large Plug

    Fantasy for Her Little Gem Large Plug

    $22.99
    In stock
    Only 6 left - Order Soon!
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  34. Luxe Candy Rimmer Silicone Anal Plug Large
    Sold Out

    Luxe Candy Rimmer Silicone Anal Plug Large

    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  35. Mood Naughty Silicone Anal Plug Large -21%

    Mood Naughty Silicone Anal Plug Large

    $27.75
    In stock
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  36. Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Medium -23%

    Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Medium

    $25.50
    In stock
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+
  37. Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Large -21%

    Mood Naughty 2 Silicone Anal Plug Large

    $27.75
    In stock
    Fast FREE Delivery Orders $49+

37 Items

Set Descending Direction
Filter
View as
class="block-title filter-title" data-count="0"> Filter By Butt Plugs
Shopping Options
Stock
  1. In Stock 29 items
  2. More on the Way (Request Stock Alerts) 8 items
On Sale
  1. On Sale 26 items
  • Butt Plugs 37 items
Size
4.25 inches
4.25 inches 3 items
4.5 inches
4.5 inches 1 item
Medium
Medium 6 items
Large
Large 9 items
4 inches
4 inches 1 item
6.5 inches
6.5 inches 1 item
2.2 inches
2.2 inches 1 item
4.8 inches
4.8 inches 2 items
3.25 inches
3.25 inches 1 item
2.4 inches
2.4 inches 1 item
Brand
  1. Blush Novelties 9 items
  2. Calexotics 3 items
  3. Doc Johnson 16 items
  4. New Sensations 2 items
  5. NS Novelties 2 items
  6. Pipedream Products 3 items
  7. XR Brands 3 items
Less
Color
Black 8 items
Blue 11 items
Purple 2 items
Pink 7 items
Yellow 2 items
Multi-Color 3 items
Less
Insertable Length
  1. Up to 5 inches 19 items
Less
Length
  1. Up to 5 inches 16 items
  2. 5 to 7 inches 3 items
Less
Price
  1. $0.00 - $99.99 34 items
  2. $100.00 - $199.99 3 items